RSS Feed

Guide books aren’t going to die. Online guides & apps aren’t necessarily up to date.

My right eye is twitching.

I’m 32–almost 33–and I don’t wear glasses or contact lenses. Never have. But these might just be the two projects that change all that. I’ve even taken a weekend offline (well, mostly offline) and the visual fatigue doesn’t seem to be getting better.

For the past two weeks, I’ve been fact checking and updating an online travel guide. The work involves scanning the seemingly infinite fields of an Internet database and making sure all the information–address, phone number, website, days/hours of operation, and lots of little details–are all current. I tick off boxes, delete defunct URLs, and switch between screens to enter information, usually while running back and forth to the kitchen to make verification phone calls (the kitchen is the only place where we get decent phone reception). Finally, late on a Saturday night, the work is finished. For today, at least, we can be sure that the information about the 225 businesses is correct.


I’ve also been working, for months now, on an iPhone app. I have complete control of the entries I want to include, but the same basic information has to be sourced and verified for each. More phone calls, more (usually fruitless) Googling. More cutting and pasting, and squinting at the computer screen for hours. Can the person on the other end of the line repeat the days and hours again? And again?

“Well, keep in mind, these are only seasonal hours,” one restaurant owner tells me at the end of a call. “This will all change next week.” “Things have been slow lately,” a shopkeeper tells me. “So we close at 5, sometimes at 6.” I hang up the phone and rub my eyes. Again.


There’s a pervasive myth that printed guide books are soon to be relegated to obscurity, destined to become curious historical artifacts that document our 20th and 21st century travel interests. The myth spreads because people believe the Internet and apps provide a logical, real-time replacement of the guide book. The information in a guide book is outdated before the book even hits the shelves. The information on the Internet, in contrast, is considered  up to date.


Having worked on all three types of guides now–the traditional printed guide book, the online travel guide, and an iPhone app–I know that the argument is largely baseless… at least for Puerto Rico. A business’ days and hours, the payment methods it accepts, its very existence… they’re all subject to quotidian developments like rising rents, corporate takeovers,technological innovations, owner fatigue, and seasonal slumps. Phone numbers get disconnected. Mindspring email accounts are replaced by gmail. 300 slot machines are now 324. Believe me, that may not , matter to you, but it matters to someone, and they’re going to be pissed if the information you provide is wrong.


When it comes right down to it, these three forms of guides aren’t all that different.

The business travel guide to Guadalajara I updated in 2008–which is online–has just come up for a revision. That’s two full years–about the same life cycle as an update for most guide books. The information on the iPhone will only be as current as my updates are. I’ve got the ambitious goal of doing a monthly update, but setting up the architecture for a fact check system is more time-consuming than you’d think.

The take-away for people who depend upon travel guides should be obvious enough. Don’t rely on the guide book, the online travel guide, or the mobile app to contain up-to-the-minute information that’s 100% accurate. Don’t even depend on a business’ website for the current information. Call and confirm.


3 responses »

  1. Maintaining an online guide myself, I totally hear you on this, Julie. Just because something *can* be updated frequently doesn’t mean it *is* updated frequently. As you say, things can change so quickly that it’s extremely tough to keep up. (And a lot depends on the currency and accuracy of the information that is there in the first place.)

    Funny you mention the website accuracy too. A friend of mine today learned that the visa information he got from an embassy’s website is out of date, and he now has to totally change his travel plans!

  2. I’m continually amazed by how long it takes Google Maps to process major highway construction updates. And, I mean, if they can’t get it done…

  3. Very good points, Julie and more reasons why I don’t buy into the “Print is gone. We’re all gonna die!” attitude. If I believed that I never would have got involved in writing on this level at all.

    Also, when I update my online guide, I make the decision whether that week’s highlighting post is going to be about a secret outdoor party or an art exhibition. The way we, as writers, make that decision makes our guide, be it print, online or an app, appeal to certain people and not to others. There are lots of choices out there for lots of different people who still have lots of different ideas about what they want.

    And let’s not forget that some of us still like to travel to places where you can’t get connected electronically…or is that just me?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: